How We Became Posthuman: Virtual Bodies in Cybernetics, Literature, and Informatics

From Cyborg Anthro Wiki

Author

N. Katherine Hayles (b. 1943), American literary critic and media theorist. Trained first as a chemist, she took a doctorate in English and became the leading scholar of the relationship between literature, cybernetics and information theory. She taught at UCLA and Duke University.

Publication Details

How We Became Posthuman: Virtual Bodies in Cybernetics, Literature, and Informatics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999. 350 pp. ISBN 978-0-226-32146-2 (paperback).[1] Winner of the René Wellek Prize of the American Comparative Literature Association.

Description

Hayles opens with a question about a historical moment: how did it come to seem obvious that information could be separated from the material substrate carrying it? Her answer is a history in three waves of cybernetics, braided with readings of science fiction, and it is also an argument against the conclusion that history produced.

The first wave (roughly 1945–1960), organised around the Macy Conferences, established homeostasis and feedback as the central concepts and — in the choice of Claude Shannon's definition of information as a probability function decoupled from meaning — made the fateful abstraction. Hayles reconstructs the moment in the Macy transcripts where Donald MacKay's alternative, which would have tied information to the change it produced in a receiver, lost out. The second wave (1960–1980), through Humberto Maturana and Francisco Varela's autopoiesis and Heinz von Foerster's second-order cybernetics, put the observer back inside the system. The third wave, from the 1980s, is the turn to emergence, artificial life and evolutionary computation.

Running alongside is a literary history — Bernard Wolfe's Limbo, Philip K. Dick, Greg Bear, Neal Stephenson's Snow Crash — read not as illustration but as a site where the cultural work of the abstraction was done.

Key Ideas

  • Information lost its body. The central historical claim. Information came to be theorised as pattern rather than presence, and the body it always in fact required was reconceived as a mere carrier.
  • Pattern/randomness displaces presence/absence. The dialectic that organised print culture is replaced by one appropriate to codes and noise, with consequences for how identity, meaning and the self are understood.
  • The liberal humanist subject. Hayles argues the posthuman does not follow from the liberal humanist subject's abolition so much as from its continuation by other means: the fantasy of downloading consciousness is possessive individualism with the body finally, fully owned and discarded.
  • Embodiment versus the body. "The body" is a normative abstraction; embodiment is particular, contextual and enacted. Only the first can be dispensed with, and only in theory.
  • A posthuman worth wanting. Hayles's closing move is not rejection but redirection — a posthumanism that recognises distributed cognition and human–machine coupling without accepting the immortality fantasy attached to it.

Criticism

Some historians of science have found the Macy narrative selective; some critics find the literary readings carrying more argumentative weight than they can bear. The book's core distinction between embodiment and the body has nonetheless become standard equipment in the field.

Relevance to Cyborg Anthropology

Alongside Haraway's "A Cyborg Manifesto," this is the foundational text for treating the human–machine relation as historical rather than natural. Its insistence that information is never bodiless is the premise on which any anthropology of technology has to rest.

References

  1. ↑ How We Became Posthuman, University of Chicago Press.